CH 5. Camel Nutrition

The importance of good nutrition in camels

Nutrition of the camel is fundamental to growth, reproduction and production. Optimum nutrition is essential for it has a profound impact on fertility, foetal growth, birth weight and also the future milk yield. Good nutrition implies that the camel must get sufficient proteins, energy, roughage, minerals and water. Comparative studies between camels and other livestock show that the camel has lower food intake in relation to body weight than any other livestock species.

  • Protein is important for growth and milk production
  • Energy enables camels to walk around in search of pastures and water
  • Roughage enhances feed intake and digestion
  • Minerals are important in reproduction, formation of bones, feed digestion and absorption and milk yield, among others
  • Water is useful in transportation of nutrients, air and wastes through the body systems and in temperature regulation.

Feeding habits

  • Foraging camels spread over a large area thus minimizing pressure on a particular forage species and area i.e. low trampling and soil disturbance,
  • The cleft on the upper lip helps camels in diet selection i.e. removing leaves from stems and picking acacia pods from the ground,
  • The lips are thick and the upper lip is divided and very sensitive, suited to pick leaves from small branches i.e. nibbling. The small tongue is good enough to hold the leaves. The camels can consume even the little branches that contain thorn quite comfortably.
  • On the average, protein content of diets selected by camels is higher than for other livestock,
  • The long legs and neck enable camels to browse up to 3 m above the ground, a height not reached by other livestock
  • Due to their specific forage preferences and feeding at higher levels, camels are rarely in direct competition with other animals (notably cattle and sheep) for grazing and therefore a combination of these species results to increased productivity per unit of land.

Suitable camel feeds

Given the opportunity, camels prefer to feed on shrubs and trees (browsing). However, in the absence of browse forages they can comfortably live on herbs and annual grasses. The concept of planted forages is not applicable in the Kenya situation where camels are reared under extensive free range systems. What is practical is to manage the natural forages in a way that promotes growth of palatable and quality shrubs that camels prefer. Keeping a mixture of camels and small stock or cattle where possible helps in maintaining the required forage composition.

  • A camel requires 8-10 hours of grazing daily to be satisfied. This depends on breed, body size and feed availability. They disperse easily therefore the herdsman must be on the look out to keep them together.
  • In an ideal situation, camels are able to select a high-quality diet that provides all the nutrients required by the body
  • Camels are also able to survive on low quality fibrous roughages. They adapt well to different diets and dietary conditions
  • During the dry season, when other forages are scarce, camels can browse on the green tips of trees (e.g. Acacia sp.) that other livestock species do not, enabling them to survive droughts,
  • It is worth noting that there are some plants that can poison camels e.g. Capparis tomentosa and Solanum spp and areas where such plants are concentrated should be avoided.

Dwarf shrubRufile MaratelKhoroEmakwiLkitagesiKorategala Kiltipe
Dwarf shrubDarran-adHadumAduungDurte
ShrubGhalangal DakkiyahYororErdungSerichoiGalgacha
TreeKulumEroronyitSarai IlbuleiBadhan Baddana
Shrub
Shrub
Shrub

Acacia tortilisGrowth form:Tree. Local names: Somali-Abuk Abak, Rendille-Dahar,Turkana-Etir Ewoi,Samburu-Ltepes,Gabbra-Dadacha
Acacia niloticaGrowth form:Tree. Local names: Somali-Bili Madow, Rendille-Gillorit,Turkana-Ekalapelimet,Samburu-Ilkiloriti,Gabbra-Burquqe
Indigofera spinosaGrowth form:Dwarf Shrub. Local names: Somali-Rufile Maratel, Rendille-Khoro,Turkana-Emakwi,Samburu-Lkitagesi,Gabbra-Korategala Kiltipe
Salsola dendroidesGrowth form:Dwarf Shrub. Local names: Somali-Darran-ad, Rendille-Hadum,Turkana-,Samburu-Aduung,Gabbra-Durte
Boscia coriaceaGrowth form:Shrub. Local names: Somali-Ghalangal Dakkiyah, Rendille-Yoror,Turkana-Erdung,Samburu-Serichoi,Gabbra-Galgacha
Balanites aegyptiacaGrowth form:Tree. Local names: Somali-Kullen Kidthi, Rendille-Kulum,Turkana-Eroronyit,Samburu-Sarai Ilbulei,Gabbra-Badhan Baddana
Salvadora persicaGrowth form:Shrub. Local names: Somali-Adde Atheii, Rendille-Hayei,Turkana-Esekon,Samburu-Sokotei,Gabbra-Aadhe
Euphorbia tirucalliGrowth form:Shrub. Local names: Somali-, Rendille-,Turkana-Elila,Samburu-Loile,Gabbra-Anno
Cordia sinensisGrowth form:Shrub. Local names: Somali-Mared Mareer, Rendille-Gaer,Turkana-Edome,Samburu-Ilgoita,Gabbra-Madeera
Barleria SppGrowth form:Herb. Local names: Somali-Gamaadiis Odarol, Rendille-Geidow Sucha,Turkana-,Samburu-Lkurumbule Sucha,Gabbra-Maadek Shiisha
Blepharis linarifoliaGrowth form:Herb. Local names: Somali-Quarda Yumarook, Rendille-Lemaruk Harja,Turkana-,Samburu-Emarak,Gabbra-Kutumbule Baraata

Feed digestion

Camels are pseudo ruminants. The camel ruminates, chewing cud mostly at night, but though there are similarities in stomach construction, the camel stomach has only 3 chambers with no clear distinction between omasum and abomasum. Camels digest cellulose better than other ruminants. The camel has no gall bladder therefore no bile salt to assist in digestion of fat. Further, camels have lower metabolic rates than other livestock, helping them to utilize their feed very efficiently and minimize water intake.

Mineral requirements

  • Camels are known to prefer grazing and browsing on salty plants, suggesting higher requirement for salts.
  • Pastoralists are aware that camels require salt and some make efforts to take their camels to naturally occurring salt sources.
  • Suggested salt allowances under normal dryland conditions range between 30 and 60 g/day. A camel working hard in the hot season may need as much as 140 g of salt daily.
  • Mineral deficiencies adverse affect productivity of camels
  • Research has shown that camels suffer specific mineral deficiencies due to complete lack or inadequate levels in the natural sources, which suggests need for properly formulated and balanced minerals for camels. One option is to buy industrial chemicals especially those containing phosphorus (dicalcium phosphate), calcium (calcium carbonate) copper, zinc, selenium, magnesium (copper sulphate, zinc sulphate, magnesium sulphate) that will supply key and commonly deficient elements and mix them with natural mineral licks or other livestock salt available in the market. The mixing ratio however needs to be guided by an expert as it depends on the difference between what the camels can get from the grazing resources and their daily requirements. Regular moving of camel herds to places with natural salts (water, licks or plant) for supplementation do help to some extent. 

Water requirements

Compared to other livestock, the camel is the most efficient in water utilization in the body by being able to reabsorb most of the water in the intestines and kidneys leading to dry feacal pellets and concentrated urine, avoiding water loss through evaporation, among others. Camels also have capacity to utilize metabolic water by recycling urea. Water requirements in camels depends on the water content of the forage and accessibility to water but is lower in relation to body weight than other livestock species .

During wet periods, camels get sufficient water from the feed and may not require direct watering. However, during dry seasons and drought periods, camels require regular watering, the recommended interval being 5 to 8 days. Watering intervals longer than this leads to dehydration which interferes with the functioning of the body systems and may reduce productivity. Watering intervals during drought of up to 14 days have however been reported. Dehydration in camels could be tested by the skin elasticity. This is done by grabbing and pulling out the loose skin e.g. the neck or lower part of the abdomen and then you release. If the skin reverts back to it normal position quickly, it suggests that the animal may not require water.

Supplementary feeding in camels

However, if the skin takes long to revert to its normal position, this suggests significant degree of dehydration. Under normal circumstances camels, can get enough and quality diet from natural vegetation. This implies that in traditional extensive systems with enough browse and water, extra feeding may not be beneficial. However during periods of feed scarcity or under peri-urban production systems, supplementary feeding would certainly be beneficial to camels particularly the pregnant, lactating camels and calves.

Supplementation can be achieved through harvesting and storage of some feed material e.g. acacia pods especially for the settled households.
The nutritional quality of natural vegetation is highest at the time when vegetation is beginning to dry up and this would be the most appropriate harvesting time.
Grass hay, minerals supplements and concentrates like dairy cubes could be bought from the market and fed to camels. However, this may prove expensive and only affordable for a few high yielding breeds like Pakistani.

CH 4. Calving management and calf rearing

What the herder/helper* should doWhy
Separate the camel from
the rest of the herd and
keep it in the boma 
You can keep a close eye
on her
Be near the camel She might need assistance
In case of difficult calving, pull out the calf gently
(after washing hands and equip- ment thoroughly)
This is to avoid damage of the uterus or injuring the
calf
Make the mother lie down
to ensure that the calf is
not dropped while the
mother is standing 
Dropping the calf while the mother is standing can
injure the calf 
Remove birth fluids on the calf body particularly
around the nose
Removing fluids from the
nose and body is meant to avoid suffocation of the
calf and pneumonia due to cold and possible death
since camels do not lick
their calves 
Treat the cut end of the
umbilical cord with some
iodine, strong salt solution or just tie it in a knot or with a string that is either
boiled or disinfected with
Dettol or Savlon 
These measures prevents entry of bacteria or foreign bodies which may cause
secondary infection
Put the calf in front of the mother until the mother
makes some low groaning noise 

Groaning normally
indicates her acceptance
of the calf


Assist the calf to suckle
and if the mother refuses
to suckle her calf which is especially common with
first calvers, smear the
mother with some birth
fluids around the nostrils. If she still proves difficult,
isolate her so that she only see the calf around her.
This helps in forcing her to accept the calf. In case of
death of the mother, cover the foster mother with hide of the dead mother to
enhance acceptance.
Early suckling (the first 3 to 6 hours) is very important because of colostrum**
which gives the calf
essential immunity to
infections in the first few
months of life 
Note: If mother dies before two months post birth, the calf rarely survives. 
Must witness dropping of
placenta although
retention is very rare; can
also be removed manually
Retained afterbirth in
camels may lead to severe post-birth complications 

* It is advisable to call an experienced herder, community based animal health worker (CBAHW) or veterinarian to assist in complicated birth
** The dense milk that animals produce for the first 2 to 3 days after giving birth. The antibodies in the colostrum can pass the intestinal wall and enter the blood during the first hours after birth.

Additional calving management tips If the calf has breathing difficulties soon after birth, do the following; 

  • Cold water poured over the chest and head has the effect of shock and makes the calf raise and shake the head
  • Massaging with two fingers from the eyes along the nose to the nostrils clears out the mucus
  • Irritation of the nostrils with a straw makes the calf sneeze and expel the mucus
  • Turn the calf upside down (for example by putting its rear legs across your shoulder and get someone to hold them there) with its head towards the ground and massage the chest moving down towards the head

Note: Do not reach into the mouth with your fingers!! This can cause an infection and diarrhea in the calf.

Calf Rearing

Colostrum feeding

Allow unlimited access of the calf to the antibodies, vitamins, proteins rich and easily digestible colostrum within the 1st 3 to 6 hours. If the dam does not produce milk, induce the let down by palpating the udder and the abdomen. In the absence of milk from the mother, feed the calf on milk from other camels. Note: Herders sometimes deny or give very little colostrum to the calves, claiming that excess colostrum causes diarrhea, especially among the second calvers . Research has shown that irregular feeding and bacterial infection causes the diarrhea and not the colostrum. Other causes includes worms and ingestion of dirt

  • Colostrum gives the calf passive immunity and washes the stomach
  • The quality of colostrum depreciates with time
  • Antibodies are proteins, and can only pass through the walls of the intestines in the first 24 hours after birth

Housing

Camel calves need to be protected against cold especially at night. The pen can be made with thick and strong bushes cut from the surrounding. The pen should be swept at least once a week to avoid accumulation of ecto- parasites

  • Over-exposure to cold breeze can cause pneumonia and death, a strongly built pen protect calves from predators while regular cleaning helps in control of ticks

Tick control

Ticks contribute significantly to the high camel calf mortality. A camel keeper should thoroughly wash young calves with acaricides e.g. triatix once in two weeks or even shorter interval depending on the tick load

  • Ticks cause paralysis and eventual death of the calves if not controlled

Diarrhea management

Note: Different camel keeping communities use different traditional methods to manage diarrhea. However, these methods are largely ineffective as evidenced by high mortality rates. Effective modern and traditional methods of managing diarrhea are explained below.

Method 1: Rehydration of the calf using a mixture of water, table salt and sugar/honey

  • Take three table spoonfuls of sugar or honey and one and half table spoonfuls of table salt and mix with three litres of clean water 
  • Give a soda bottle (300mls) full of this solution through the mouth on four hourly intervals until the diarrhea stops. 
  • Diarrhea contributes significantly to the 12-60% camel calf mortality levels reported among camel herds in Kenya
  • When a calf has diarrhea, it looses a lot of water that leads to death if not replenished. The honey-table salt-water solution has rehydrating and treatment effects

Method 2: Traditionally eggs from chickens which interact with camels is used 

  • Give one egg by the mouth daily to a calf with diarrhea until it stops.
  • The eggs of chicken which interacts with camels and feed on ticks and other flies from camels have been observed to have both treatment and preventive effects on the diarrhea

Method 3: Use of conventional drugs 

  • Give sulphur based drugs e.g. S-dime tablets according to manufacturer’s instructions
  • Note: The sick calf should continue suckling, be kept in a clean environment and separated from the healthy ones until it recovers
  • These measures prevents spread of the diarrhea to other calves

Calf management in the first four months of growth

  • Let the calf run with its mother during the day for the first three months 
  • After the third month when the calf is able to graze actively, gradually reduce the milk allowance depending on the quantity and quality of forage available and its growth performance
  • In case of death of the mother or calf rejection, bottle feeding is advised 
  • This allows the calf adequate milk. Heavy milking for human consumption at this stage negatively affects calf growth rate hence delaying its reproductive and physical maturity 
  • Early separation contribute to calf diarrhea since such a calf stays hungry the whole day and when the mother returns home in the evening, it takes a lot of milk at one suckling. The milk tends to cramp the undeveloped stomach leading to diarrhea. 
  • Letting the calf accompany its mother during the day also triggers early rumination because of early access to forage and water

Management of the non suckling calves (weaners)

  • Gradually wean (dry) the calf from suckling
  • Deworm at weaning 
  • Vaccinate the weaners for trypanosomosis
  • Feed the weaners on good quality forage
  • Gradually increase the watering interval 
  • Supplement with minerals 
  • Wash weaners for external parasites
  • Camel keepers wean the calves at an average age of one year. Under pastoral management, calves before weaning mostly graze around and are watered at home. However, after weaning the calves join the main herd that is normally subjected to long distance foraging and watering. This abrupt change in management contributes to stress which may be disastrous to the calf. The practices outlined here minimize the stress. 
  • Additional methods of managing diarrhea in camel calves (this works in some cases with cattle calves, dose may need to be increased for camel calves) 
  • Drench with Kaolin (about 2 handfuls in a soda bottle mixed with a bit of cud from the mothers mouth and filled with clean (preferably boiled and cooled) water. Drench at least twice per day until symptoms disappear. 
  • Charcoal drench: Crush charcoal very finely. Put about 2 handfuls in a soda bottle, fill clean water and shake. Drench morning and evening. 

CH 3. Breeding Practices

Characteristics of good breeding bull and female 

Bull 

  • High milk production capability among daughters
  • Fast growth rate
  • Good body conformation (tall, large body frame and well built), upright in standing, high ability to chase and mount females and
  • Adaptable to the environment (feed availability, terrain suitability etc)

Female

  • History of producing high milk volume 
  • No history of diseases
  • Good adaptability to the environment
  • Good body conformation (slender body and large stomach)
  • Well developed and pronounced milk veins 
  • Large and well set udder with four teats
  • Good mothering ability and no history of stillbirths, abortions etc 

Recommended bull: female ratio

  • The camel keeper should maintain one dominant bull of between 6 to 12 years with one younger bull as his replacement. In some areas, breeding bulls are shared with the neighbors or even with the community.
  • However, more than one breeding bull may be required depending on the herd size
  • A bull: female ratio of 1:50 is appropriate when sufficient forage is available

Sexual maturity 

  • Females become active at 4 to 5 years of age and give birth when about 5 to 6 years old. Although sexual maturity varies with breed, it is very much dependent on management level in terms of nutrition and health. When enough good feed is available, camels develop faster and maturity will be at an earlier age.
  • Males attain sexual maturity at around 5 years but begins to serve actively at around 6 years when their canine teeth are sufficiently developed for fighting 

Breeding season

  • Camels are seasonal breeders. The breeding season coincides with the cool rainy period of the year. 
  • Release of the egg (ovulation) in females is initiated (induced) by mating. This means conception only take place during the second mating which should take place after 20 – 25 days when the heat cycle returns after the first attempt to mate.

Mating

  • Mating among camels is a violent affair and can lead to injury in females. Precautions should be taken, and they should be taken care of by physically strong people.
  • Keep the breeding bull separate from the females especially when rutting since it can physically injure the females and the calves.
  • Sometimes the female does not voluntarily sit and she is forced to do so by the male who often chases her around, biting her neck, back of the hump, and pressing her down. This may result in severe wounds to the female. It is advisable to make the female sit before bringing the male to mate with her,
  • The mating process takes about 15 minutes 
  • It is also advisable that rutting males are herded by strong, mature people since they can easily hurt children.

Pregnancy diagnosis

  • A traditional method of telling if a camel is pregnant, is to stand near it and raise your hand, then check for the raising of the tail and passing of some urine. If it does so, this indicates pregnancy,
  • A pregnant camel will also raise her tail when a bull approaches her, 
  • The camel begins to show this sign 2 – 4 weeks after conception. 

Signs of rut in male

  • Loss of appetite and condition
  • Unusually aggressive and difficult to handle (Chases away all the other males and even humans)
  • Frequent urination and splashing urine on the back by flicking the tail, 
  • Prolific secretion from the poll glands situated behind the ears and rubbing the secretion onto plants as a way of marking its territory
  • Protrusion of a soft palatal flap from the mouth (with air, in form of a pink balloon as shown in the picture below)
  • Making characteristic noises and continuously grinding their teeth with saliva flowing from the mouth 
  • Rutting bulls should be separated as they may fight to death

Signs of heat in female camels

  • She may become restless 
  • May show swelling of the vulva and mucous discharge
  • Frequent urination
  • Making characteristic noise
  • May have reduced milk yield
  • May sniff urine from other females
  • The heat is repeated after 20 – 25 days for females that fail to conceive

Recommended breeding practices and their advantages
1. Avoid inbreeding by:

  • Replacing the breeding bull at 12 years when its first daughters becomes sexually mature
  • Exchanging bulls with neighbors
  • Use of two or more breeding bulls

Advantages

  • Minimizes congenital/inherent problems e.g. deformities
  • Enhance calf growth 
  • Reduce calf mortality

2. Use bulls younger than 13 years
Advantages

  • Young bulls have high ability to follow and mount females 
  • Young bulls come to rut faster after the dry season and serve for a longer period in any given breeding season
  • Young and active bulls ensures higher conception rates of females
  • Retired bulls can be castrated and fattened for meat or other uses

3. Use females of less or equal to 6 calvings 
Advantages

  • These are young females who normally have good body condition 
  • Produce more milk for the calf and humans and their calves show higher growth rate 

4. To upgrade your camels through cross breeding, look for a bull with the traits you desire
Advantage

  • A bull propagates desired traits in a herd very fast as it has capacity to serve 50 dams in a breeding season. A female can only give birth to one calf at a time and it takes a long long time before you have introduced the desired traits into the herd.

Care of pregnant camels, a month before giving birth

  • Closely monitor the camels as this is the most critical stage
  • Graze the camels near settlement or boma as they may require some assistance in giving birth
  • Avoid grazing such camels in areas with pot holes, gulleys, rocky areas, slippery grounds since such camels may easily fall down and severely injure themself
  • Do not allow the camels to wallow in the soil
  • Do not put such camels in sloppy bomas as it is difficult to stand on such a ground 

Signs of labor

  • Enlargment of the udder 
  • Sagging of the ligaments at the root of the tail 
  • Restlessness including lying down and standing up
  • Loss of appetite
  • Make characteristic noise
  • Isolating themselves from other camels 

CH. 2 Camel breeds in Kenya

The 3 main breeds of camel found in Kenya are Somali, Rendille/Gabbra and Turkana. These are kept by communities who bear the same names as those of the breed. There is a fourth breed of camel called Pakistani which was imported from Pakistan into Laikipia ranches in Kenya in the early 1990s. However, only a few pure Pakistan camels exist while crosses with Somali or Turkana breeds have since moved out of Laikipia to Samburu, East Pokot, Kajiado, Northern Tanzania, Mandera and Marsabit districts. Following is a description of these breeds; 

Somali Camel

Somali Camels
(c)Somalilandpress

Purpose:

  • Good for milk production as it can give 3 to 5 liters in a day
  • Milking the camel three times a day guarantees even more milk
  • Lactation length is 1 to 1.5 years

Body color:

  • Cream/brown 

Mature body weight:

  • Ranges from 450 – 850 kg
  • First calving occurs between 4 – 5 years
  • Average standing height is 2 meters when mature 

Feed requirements: 

  • Heavy feeders requiring 8 to 12 hours of feeding in a day depending on feed availability
  • Are more comfortable feeding on shrubs because of their height 

Advantages:

  • More milk
  • Matures early

Disadvantages:

  • Cannot be reared in areas with rough terrain or rocky hillsides due to large size
  • Suffer more when feed availability is low 

Within the Somali breed are four sub-types namely Hoor, Siftarr, Aidimo and Gelab. These differ in physical, production and adaptability characteristics. While hoor is the highest milk producing sub-type, it is the least hardy. Gelab on the other hand is the smallest in body size, least milk producing but most hardy. 

Rendille/Gabbra Camel

Rendille Camels
(c)Mette Vaarst

Milk yield:

  • 1 – 3 liters per day
  • Lactation length of 1 to 1.5 years

Body color:

  • Cream or brown

Mature body weight:

  • 300 – 550 kg 
  • First calving occurs between 5 – 6 years 
  • Average standing height is 1.8 meters 
  • Feed requirements: Less than Somali, requiring 8 – 10 hours of grazing 

Advantages: 

  • Does better under poor pasture conditions and rough terrain 
  • Tolerate drought conditions better than Somali 

Disadvantage:

  • Lower milk yield
  • Late maturity

Turkana Camel

Turkana Camels
(c)Mette Vaarst

Milk yield:

  • Lower than Somali and Rendille/Gabbra that is, 1 to 2.5 liters/day 
  • Lactation length of about 1 year

Body color:

  • Mainly grayish/dark

Mature body weight:

  • 250 – 500kg

First calving:

  • Occurs between 5 and 6 years of age
  • Average standing height is 1.7 meters
  • Feed requirements is less than that of Gabbra/Rendille, requiring about 7 hours of grazing

Advantages:

  • Most hardy of all the breeds
  • Very agile and able to climb steep lava hills because of small body size
  • Least affected under situation of feed scarcity 

Disadvantages:

  • Least milk yield
  • Matures late

Pakistani Camel

Pakistani Camels
(c)Mette Vaarst

Purpose:

  • Of all the breeds, this is the best for milk production
  • Produces 4 – 7 liters of milk daily under ranch conditions 

Body color:

  • Predominantly chocolate 
  • Mature body weight: 400 – 700 kg
  • Invariably drooping lower lip

First calving:

  • Occurs between 4-5 years of age
  • Averages standing height 1.9 meters

Feed requirements:

  • It is a heavy feeder

Advantages:

  • High milk yield

Disadvantages: 

  • Insufficiently tested on rough terrain
  • Less hardy

Note: Across all the breeds, males are generally heavier than females

CH 1. Camels-Introduction

Camels
(c) Anne Bruntse, Biovision

Introduction

Origin of camels, including dromedaries

Camels are thought to have been introduced into East Africa by Somali speaking communities over 1000 years ago. These early pastoralists also had cattle, sheep and goats, but camels were better adapted to the dry climate and deteriorating rangeland of Northern Kenya and other dry areas of Africa. They contribute greatly to human survival in dry areas. Historically camels arrived in the region only after deserts had been created by overgrazing and the following land degradation. Perhaps had the camels come before the desert would not have followed, as camels do not deteriorate lands at the same rates as other livestock. They have no hoofs to destroy the fragile soils and they are mainly browsers, meaning grasslands do not become depleted where camels have fed. Camels produce milk throughout the lactation period, whereas cows and small stock dry up during droughts and prolonged dry spells. The total number of camels globally is said to be 20 million, but as most camels are owned by nomads, this number can only be estimated.

Understand camels as the animals they are

Camels come from the most barren and harsh places on our planet. Everything in the camel is designed to trap or save moisture; even their blood cells are different in order to deal with less water. They need more salt than most animals. They are not considered ‘real ruminants’, but they have a 3-compartment stomach and do regurgitate and rechew ingested forage, and they are very efficient in getting sufficient energy even from poor feed. Their body temperature can raise up to 6oC without troubling them seriously, and is often under air temperature. They can walk 3-5 days on almost no food.

They have a very good sight, and their eyes are surrounded by long lashes to protect them against winds and sand. and 34 sharp teeth which allow them to chew almost anything. Despite that they come from dry areas, they are good swimmers. Naturally they will rest during the hot days and feed in the cooler evenings.

A camel family would normally consist of a single male, one to many females and a group of young animals. The male ensures that the cows in the family avoid contact with strangers. Even though they are attacked and eaten by lions and other predators, they were not confronted with natural predators in their original dry environment. Some have explained their calm behavior by this fact: they are patient, quite bold, calm and observing, and rarely panic. They can in some cases confront threatening animals, rather than trying to escape. They have an excellent memory, and can find their way and remember people who did not treat them well. The picture of them as ‘stubborn’ and disobedient is completely wrong – they are normally very collaborative with humans.

Camels in East Africa and Kenya

All camels in Kenya are dromedaries or one-humped Arabian camels. Camels are used as multifunctional animals in pastoral production systems of east Africa with the general aim of producing milk, meat, blood, hides and skins, provision of transport, barter trade (sale and exchange), and social and cultural functions. Camels have an outstanding milk production, even in harsh environments, compared with cattle and small stocks under the same harsh environmental conditions. Their lactation persists well into the dry seasons and rarely ceases even during extended dry spells. Camel’s milk is preferred to milk of other livestock species because of its taste, nutritious value, health reasons and it is perceived that camel milk prevents thirst even when walking for a long distances. Depending on the accessibility of the market, surplus camel milk is also sold for cash income by members of the communities. Meat production from camels is less important in the east African region due to low reproductive performance as compared to cattle and small stocks. Small stocks are the main source of meat to the pastoral communities, but camels are slaughtered for meat on some occasions.

Camel milk is slightly saltier than cows’ milk, three times as rich in Vitamin C and is known to be rich in iron, unsaturated fatty acids and B vitamins, and is by some recommended to HIV/AIDS patients, and may play a role in reducing diabetes and coronary heart disease. It is a natural and essential food item in areas where there is a scarcity of water and forage. There may be 200 mill. potential customers in Africa. With improved feed, water and husbandry they can yield up to 20 litres per day.

Pastoralists emphasize that camels have a better meat quality because of the nutritive value and taste. Most camels are slaughtered at home for domestic consumption and the excess meat sold through a butcher. Camels are also regarded as a source of hides and skins, which are valuable raw materials for building huts and manufacturing utensils. Additionally camels are a source of blood that is mixed with milk to form a diet component for the young warriors who are also herders. Camels also have social and cultural functions including social transactions like gifts, loans to relatives and friends and food supply at the occasion of ceremonies. Sale and exchange of camels only occurs during droughts or when pastoralists are in need of high amounts of cash, such as for paying hospital fees or school fees. These unique and strategic uses of camel and related products explain the importance of the camel in the Samburu community. Despite all the benefits associated with camel production in the pastoral areas of East Africa, camels still faces challenges in their natural environment including camel diseases, drought and predation which expose the pastoralist to risks of loosing their source of livelihood.

Sustainable Management, alternatives for pastoralists – vegetabe farms

Recurrent droughts and subsequent livestock deaths, as well as the closing off of important migration routes due to privatization of sections of the drylands for large-scale agriculture, are forcing pastoralists to diversify into agriculture and the market economy. Women are playing a key role in pastoralists’ diversification in taking up agicultural activities and build up small vegetable farms, according to a recent report published by the Regional Learning and Advocacy Programme (REGLAP).

Former pastoralist families and officials report of being no longer dependent on food aid and malnutrition and anemia have both declined since the agriculture effort began. They depended on milk, meat or relief maize. Now, their children eat fruits and vegetables, something they never had before. Frequent hospital visits have reduced drastically (main crops grown are onion, beans, green vegetables, tomotoes, peas, watermelon, chilli, maize, coffee, grain and banana). 

CH 10. Acknowledgements and References

Acknowledgment:

The Asal Based Livestock and Rural Livelihoods Support Project (ALLPRO) with a grant from The African Development Bank commissioned a study (2006–2009) into Marketing of camel milk and meat and their products. The study was undertaken by International Livestock Research Institute (ILRI), Kenya Agriculture Research Institute (KARI), Kenya Camel Association (KCA) and ALLPRO and published under the name: study of marketing, processing and Value adding of camel milk and meat products in the ASAL region of Kenya (hereafter called “the study”).

This study has lead to a greater understanding of some of the indigenous products and as a result two manuals have been produced: (1) Camel Milk: A Practical guide to Hygienic Production and Handling for Improved Market access as well as (2) Camel Meat: Guide to Commercialising Traditional Products —A Case Study of Nyirinyiri (yet unpublished).

SpecialThanks to:

The Study team:

  • Dr. Simon Kuria (KARI, Marsabit)
  • Isaac Njoro (then ALLPRO)
  • Amos Omore (ILRI)
  • Francis Wanyoike (ILRI)
  • Anne Bruntse Nganga (then KCA)

Camel milk producers and traders in Garissa and Isiolo

GarissaReviewworkshopadditionalparticipant’sandtheirinputs toenrichthismanual:

  • Jane W. Gakure (Range Management Division, MOLD)
  • Njoroge Wamwere (then ALLPRO)
  • Ernest Mbogo (then ALLPRO)
  • Khalif Abbey (KCA)

Editors:A.B. Nganga (then KCA), Dr. James C. Njanja (KCA), Dr. Kisa Juma Ngeiywa (ALLPRO)

Biovision Foundation for Ecological Development:Funding for printing of this manual.

CHR HANSEN LABORATORIES:Funding of layout of this manual.

References and further reading

Agrawal et al. Effect of raw camel milk on type 1 diabetes patients. 1 year randomized study. Journal of Camel Practice and Research 12(1):27–31

ALLPro/iLri/KAri/KCA interim study report (2008) Consumption Patterns, Marketing Channels and Consumer Demand for Camel milk and Meat in Kenya.

Farah Z. and Fischer A. (2004) Milk and Meat from the Camel: A Handbookon products and processing. ETH Zurich. ISBN 3 7281 2527 X.

Restani et al. (1999) Clinical and Experimental Allergy 29:997–1004.

Wernery U. (2007) Camel Milk – New Observations: in Proceedings of International Camel Conference, February 2007.

Yagil r. (1982) Camels and Camel milk. FAO Animal Production and Health Paper 26.

CH 9. Marketing of camel milk

Packaging and labeling

It was shown during the KARI ARSPII project that simple packaging of milk in sealed and labeled plastic bags really enhances customer confidence and willingness to buy the product. This technology can be adapted using a solar panel so does not necessarily depend on proximity to electricity.

Product diversification

Camel milk is very popular in fresh form, and so far most customers in Kenya prefer fresh camel milk above all other products. Camel milk is also not so easy to process in to alternative products, but where the markets demand such products and are willing to pay, it is possible to make very good:

  • Feta cheese
  • Camelbert cheese (similar to brie cheese)
  • A yoghurt health drink that can further improve camel milk health benefits (this does not become thick like yoghurt from cow or goat milk)
  • Camel milk ghee (this is more of a food preservation product and visually resembles camel body fat, but chapattis fried in camel ghee taste very delicious)
  • Improved suza – a MILD alternative to traditional suza, using special milk cultures. Special camel milk cultures are under development.
  • Dried and fresh ITITU – a form of fresh cheese traditionally mostly made with goat milk, can also be made from camel milk if there is a market for such products. In areas with milk surplus this fermented product can be dried and preserved for leaner times, where it can be crushed and added to porridge and enrich the diets of children in times of shortage.
  • Camel milk sweets and candy Camel milk ice cream

Collective Marketing – advantages, dynamics

Marketing of milk – milk kiosks – groups

There is general understanding that milk customers, being concerned for the health of their families will prefer to buy milk from a clean metal container sitting on a clean table under a shade rather than from a scratched plastic jerrican sitting in the sun for several hours.

In order to be able to afford such facilities, it is an advantage to work together in groups. Working in groups can also free some time for conducting other business for all members, as they can take turns marketing all the groups’ milk. With time the groups can also decide to try out simple milk processing such as making yoghurt and mala/suza and possibly buy a fridge for better storage. All these measures will greatly improve the income earning possibilities of the groups.

MILK COOPERATIVES in other parts of the country have proven a highly successful way of collective milk marketing and processing.

Creation of awareness and market promotion

Any new product to be introduced to the market can use some of the following marketing demonstration strategies:

  1. Taste sessions during agricultural shows,
  2. Field days, etc.,
  3. Mass media adverts (print and electronic).

CH 8. Preservation of milk

As most of the informal milk market customers are looking for fresh milk, the best preservation methods include boiling, pasteurising and cooling. If there is a well paying market for fermented milk products like yoghurt or mala/suza, this can be undertaken as a special value addition for income generation project.

Boiling or pasteurising of milk

Boiling of milk will kill all disease causing germs. However the toxins produced especially mastitis by causing germs will not disappear. Mastitis milk will have to be identified at producer level.

Early last century a method of killing disease germs in milk was invented. It is called pasteurisation. Many people believe – quite rightly – that boiling of milk reduces the nutritional value of same milk. Especially the vitamin C content is reduced by boiling.

Pasteurisation in a closed milk can has several benefits over boiling milk over an open fire while stirring:

  • No or very little milk loss due to evaporation (make sure the lid is closed)
  • No skin on the milk (again make sure the lid is closed) Very little loss of vitamins
  • No burnt taste
  • No boiled taste

Pasteurisation process:

Heating milk in a water bath to 65°C for 20 minutes, or heating to 72ºC for 15 seconds then cooling quickly by transferring the milk cans to cold water bath.

 This process will kill all known disease causing germs. The cooling is also important for milk, as there can be some heat resistant spoilage bacteria that can cause the milk to curdle at high temperatures (sweet curdling). Anyone used to leaving hot milk in  a thermos flask will have seen this sweet curdling.

To determine when the milk hasreached the above temperatures we can simply measure with a food thermometer, but these are not easily available and besides are made of glass so they break easily.

NAREWAMA (FaustineOdaba“MamaSolar”–Facebook)   haveintroduced a small gadget called a “WAPI”. This is a small clear nylon tube containing a bit of green (melting at 65°C) or white (melting at 75ºC) wax and sealed in both ends.

The “WAPI” – is attached to a string and some small steel washers to keep it balanced. After use it can simply be inverted for the melted wax to again be on top for the next pasteurisation.
Immersing this wapi into the milk and checking from time to time will clearly show when the milk is hot enough – the wax has melted and sunk to the other end of the WAPI, and the milk can be cooled. Such a gadget can be bought at KSh 150/- and will last a long time provided it is not given to children to play with. It is also easy to clean and sterilise with a bit of boiling water. Using aWAPI or a thermometer can save firewood.

WAPI thermometer

Cooling of milk

Milk keeps very well under cold temperatures. However temperatures in ASAl are never cold, so temperature is a major factor affecting milk spoilage.

Some measures can be employed to lower the temperatures where you store the milk:

  • Build shaded shelters to screen out the major part of the solar heat for milk storage while waiting for transport. A shaded area is many degrees lower than the full sunshine of the environment, especially if there is a bit of wind passing through. Storing milk in a shaded area will make it keep longer
  • Try evaporation coolers.This technology has been around fora long time. The principle behind it is that water uses heat to evaporate. This heat can be taken from a small chamber storing milk and other products if properly constructed. Evaporation coolers can lower temperatures up to 10°C compared to the surrounding environment. Several designs have been tested in various parts of the world depending on available materials.

CH.7 Milk testing

How do we know if the milk we buy is of good quality?

For primary milk buyers (buying directly from producers) there are 4 useful milk testing techniques possible:

  • CMT (California mastitis test): measures whether there is major mastitis contamination in the milk (appropriate at producer level).
  • Organoleptic test: (a) look, (b) smell, (c) taste (appropriate at all levels).
  • Lactometer:measures if water has been added to milk (calibrated to cow milk at 18–20°C, so not very suitable for use in hot areas unless recalibrated).
  • Clot on boiling:measures acidity, when milk is too sour to be boiled. A table spoon of milk is held over a candle or similar to see if it boils well (appropriate
Lactometer
Clot on boiling test; if it clots the milks has gone bad
  • Alcoholtest:also measures acidity, more sensitive than clot on boiling, but needs special equipment and training in order to get reliable results.
  • Lactoscan (US$ 1000): This equipment available at around US$ 1000 (Ksh 75,000) is a very sensitive milk testing tool. Suitable for dairy associations and NGOs supporting the clean milk trade
Many models of the Lactoscan
available (please check the
internet)

CH 6. Cleaning of containers

All milk cans, containers and utensils must be properly washed and disinfected. The procedure is as follows:

  1. Wash hands with soap and rinse.
  2. Washallcontainerswithsoap ordetergentandsuperbriteorsimilar non metal scouring pad material (sisal or plastic sacking can also be used provided it is washed and boiled after use).
  3. Rinse out the soap/detergent
  4. Sterilise in boiling water
  5. Dry upside down in the sun on a clean  table  or rack. The sun is a very good steriliser as well, but care should be taken that recontamination from blowing dust does occur.
A: Rinse out the soap/detergent; B: Sterilising in boiling water; and C: Dry upside
down in the sun on a clean table or rack

Do NOT dry containers inside with any cloth. Cloths may be very dirty and can add serious contamination to an otherwise clean container.

Any cloth used for straining milk must be properly rinsed to remove milk with cold clean water after use, then washed with detergent and sterilised along with the milk cans. The boiling water can then be used as a water bath to pasteurise milk in the milk cans.

How to clean inappropriate containers

Although metal cans (aluminum or stainless steel) are the best type of milk containers, they are not always available in any practical sizes. So in the absence of proper containers, plastic jerricans are mostly used. Plastic jerricans are light, and seem practical transport containers, but they are almost impossible to clean inside. However if nothing else is available, the following cleaning procedures will give a fairly clean plastic container:

  • Rinse the jerrican for all traces of milk.
  • Boil some clean building/river sand in water, add a handful to the jerrican and use this sand for shaking around the jerrican till all spots and visible contamination has disappeared.
  • Discard the sand.
  • Repeat the washing with dishsoap or similar detergent (do not use omo – it is very diffi cult to rinse out again and will leave an unpleasant taste).
  • Rinse with clean water.
  • Sterilise with boiling water – swish the boiling water around till all corners have been sterilised.
  • Discard the water.
  • Close the container with the sterilised lid and keep it closed till you need to use it.

Water quality

Milk containers and the hands of milk handlers need to be washed with soap and clean water. Many places the available water is not clean. However all chemists can stock very cheap water purification chemicals such as Aquaguard or similar. A bottle top full of Aquaguard put into a 20L jerrican of water and left for 24 hours, will have made the mud settle and purified the water so it can be used for drinking, or cleaning udders, hands and utensils. Boiling water is also good but may not always remove all the mud. Ask the chemist for the best and cheapest water purification methods.